(Reporter Wang Qiu) to do business with in a market, Yang Zhang and his wife after an argument with the old woman, sudden cardiac death. After the incident, the family of Yang Granny Zhang will quarrel with his wife to court, and claims 62 million yuan and 100,000 yuan of economic losses in emotional. Yesterday, reporter learned that the couple should be responsible Zhang found some responsibility, Daxing Huangcun court the compensation court Granny Young families 10 million yuan.
Zhang Yang and his wife with an old woman in the village of Daxing District, Hai Zi corner a market in the business. As a peer, the two people in the business often because of a trivial conflict.
Young Granny's family said, the morning of August 16 last year, Zhang shouting for no reason in front of their home, Yang old woman asked the reason and their representations, but Zhang is not only not stop shouting, but hand pushing Yang old woman, resulting in acute heart Granny Young, died after the hospital.
November 1 last year, the Beijing Municipal Public Security Bureau issued conclusions, the Department finds that Granny Young acute rheumatic heart disease leading to heart failure death, disputes with others, or emotional shock, etc., may be disease the incentive.
Yang old woman's family believes that if his wife beatings and tear is not Zhang, Yang old woman's body was without any problems, the market knows that Yang old woman suffering from heart disease, but Chang still a sick old woman knew his Yang quarrel, and trip. After the incident, they do not have any rescue act. In view of the couple's behavior and Yang Zhang Granny's death is causal, they claim for medical expenses, death compensation, dependents and other living expenses of $ 62 million and 100,000 yuan in emotional.
court, Zhang argued that the couple is Granny Yang and his family for insulting him, he did not harm Yang old woman. They believe that Yang old woman suffering from rheumatic heart disease, but did not control their emotions, leading to their death from their own,www.buybeatsbydrdreheadphone.com, he does not agree to compensation.
Court held that the public security departments to make the conclusions of notice, that force has reached a high degree of probability standard, although Zhang and Yang Granny couple denied physical contact occurred, but not against the public security department of the inquiry record and conclusions of the formation of the chain of evidence; In addition, Zhang and his wife also failed to provide evidence to the contrary have to be negative.
Accordingly, the court with his wife and the deceased Yang Zhang Granny physical contact of the fact that the two sides of the dispute is determined old lady a heart attack led to the death of Yang incentives. Taking into account the causes of dispute and the sick old woman Yang Zhang know the plot, the court found the couple in both Zhang dispute the existence of fault behavior, should be the death of Yang Granny liability. In addition, taking into account some degree of fault Granny Yang, Zhang and his wife should be appropriate to reduce the liability, the court will ultimately determine their share of not more than 15%, and awarded compensation for Zhang Yang Granny couple families 100,000 of the total cost of yuan.
(edit: SN014)Related articles:
没有评论:
发表评论